icon

Powered by HuraTips.Com

7 Common Meat Thermometer Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

A meat thermometer is an essential tool for achieving perfectly juicy steaks, tender roasts, and ensuring food security when cooking various types of meat. Whether you’re grilling, roasting, or smoking, a meat thermometer helps take the guesswork out of cooking, ensuring you avoid both undercooking and overcooking your meat dish. Using it correctly is crucial for reaching the safe temperature for each type of meat. Many home cooks, despite using a meat thermometer, make small but significant mistakes that result in inaccurate readings, which can lead to cooked meat that is either dry or unsafe to eat.

If you’ve been struggling with inconsistent results, you may be falling into one of these common traps. Here’s how to avoid these pitfalls and ensure your meat dish is perfectly cooked every time, delivering both flavor and food security.

(Picture by @wicked.bbq)

1. Not Placing the Probe in the Thickest Part of the Meat

One of the most common meat thermometer mistakes is inserting the probe in the wrong spot. Many people instinctively stick the thermometer into the edge or close to the bone, thinking that will give an accurate temperature reading. However, these areas tend to cook faster, and bones conduct heat, making it seem like the meat is done when it’s actually still undercooked. This is a critical mistake, especially with larger cuts of raw meat like roasts or whole poultry.

For example, placing the thermometer too close to the bone in a roast will give a higher temperature reading than the rest of the meat, which may still be raw meat in the center.

How to Avoid It:
Always place the probe in the thickest part of the meat, away from bones, fat, and gristle. The thickest part of the meat takes the longest to cook and, therefore, provides the most accurate internal temperature reading. For larger cuts like roasts or whole birds, such as chicken and turkey, aim for the center of the thickest muscle. Typically, this is found in the breast or thigh area for poultry.

For smaller cuts like steaks or pork chops, insert the thermometer probe from the side, ensuring it reaches the center of the raw meat. This technique provides a more accurate reading than inserting the probe from the top, which may only measure the surface temperature of the cooked meat.

By placing the probe in the correct location, you can ensure your meat dish reaches its safe temperature, helping you avoid undercooked centers and ensuring your meal is prepared evenly and safely.

 

2. Checking the Temperature Too Late

Another frequent mistake when using a meat thermometer is waiting too long to check the internal temperature of the cooked meat. Many home cooks rely on guesswork or visual cues, such as the browning of the meat, before inserting the thermometer. However, by the time the meat "looks done," it may already be overcooked or dried out, especially when cooking larger cuts of types of meat like briskets or whole roasts.

This is one of the common grilling mistakes many people make, especially during BBQ sessions. For instance, larger cuts like briskets, roasts, or whole chickens often brown on the outside before they are fully cooked through. Relying on external appearances alone can lead to overcooked or dry cooked meat, which sacrifices flavor and texture.

How to Avoid It:
Start checking the internal temperature early, especially for large cuts that cook more slowly, like briskets, roasts, or whole birds. Instead of waiting for the meat to appear done, begin checking the meat's internal temperature about 10-15 minutes before the recommended cooking time ends.

For example, if your recipe suggests roasting a turkey for 2 hours, start checking the temperature after about 1 hour and 45 minutes. This gives you a buffer to catch the meat at the perfect doneness. Wireless meat thermometers, such as the MeatStick, make this process even easier. You can monitor the internal temperature of your meat in real-time from your phone, allowing you to track the progress without needing to open the oven or grill and disrupt the cooking process.

Starting early will ensure you pull the meat off the heat at the exact temperature, ensuring you avoid the disappointment of overcooking. Maintaining attention to food safety is crucial here, as undercooked meat can be harmful, and overcooking sacrifices the quality of your meat dish.

 

3. Not Allowing the Thermometer to Settle

Many home cooks make the mistake of pulling the thermometer out too quickly, before it has had enough time to stabilize and give an accurate reading. Instant-read thermometers, despite the name, aren’t always as instantaneous as they claim. If you remove the thermometer too soon, you may get a reading that’s too low or too high, leading you to under- or overcook the meat based on faulty information.

This issue often arises when people are in a rush to serve the meal, but it’s critical to give the thermometer time to settle for a reliable reading.

How to Avoid It:
When using a digital or instant-read thermometer, insert the probe into the thickest part of the meat and wait for the reading to stabilize. Generally, it takes about 5 to 10 seconds for the temperature to stop rising and provide an accurate reading.

If you’re using a wireless thermometer like the MeatStick, the temperature is displayed in real-time through an app or display. This allows you to monitor the temperature over time without needing to hurry the process. Patience here ensures a more accurate reading and better results.

Rushing the thermometer can lead to inaccurate readings, so allow the temperature to settle for the most reliable information. Ensuring accuracy over time is critical for achieving the perfect meat dish and ensuring the internal temperature meets the safe temperature guidelines.

 

4. Not Cleaning the Probe Between Uses

Sanitation is a crucial part of safe cooking, especially when preparing different types of meat. However, many home cooks forget to clean their thermometer probe between uses, especially when checking the temperature of multiple pieces of raw meat. Not cleaning the thermometer between uses can lead to cross-contamination, transferring harmful bacteria like salmonella or E. coli from raw meat to cooked meat.

In addition to the health risks, a dirty thermometer probe can affect the accuracy of the temperature reading. Grease or residue from previous uses can interfere with the sensor, leading to false readings.

How to Avoid It:
After each use, be sure to wipe the thermometer probe with a clean cloth or paper towel. For raw meats, especially poultry, sanitize the probe by rinsing it in hot, soapy water or using an antibacterial wipe before checking another piece of meat. This simple step eliminates the risk of cross-contamination and ensures food security when cooking.

If you’re preparing multiple types of meat or checking the same cut several times during the cooking process, make it a habit to clean the probe after each use. Proper sanitation not only protects against foodborne illnesses but also provides more accurate readings, ensuring the accuracy over time of the thermometer and maintaining attention to food safety.

 

5. Ignoring the Carryover Cooking Effect

One of the most commonly overlooked aspects of cooking types of meat is the effect of carryover cooking. When meat is removed from heat, it continues to cook for several minutes as it rests. This is especially important for larger cuts, such as roasts, briskets, or whole birds. If you don’t account for carryover cooking, your meat could end up overcooked, even if it was taken off the heat at the correct temperature.

This phenomenon occurs because the heat trapped inside the cooked meat continues to cook the internal tissues even after being removed from the oven or grill.

How to Avoid It:
To account for carryover cooking, remove your meat from the heat when the internal temperature is about 5 to 10 degrees below your target. For instance, if you are cooking chicken and aiming for a final internal temperature of 160°F, pull the meat off the heat at 150°F. As the meat rests, the internal temperature will continue to rise and reach the desired doneness.

Allow the meat to rest for at least 10 minutes after removing it from the heat. This resting period not only ensures the internal temperature reaches the correct level but also allows the juices to redistribute throughout the cooked meat, resulting in juicier, more flavorful dishes.

Ignoring carryover cooking can lead to overdone, dry types of meat, so be sure to account for this effect in your cooking. It’s also essential to pay attention to food safety by checking the internal temperature has reached a safe temperature before serving.

 

6. Relying on Color or Juices to Judge Doneness

Judging the doneness of meat based on its color or the clarity of its juices is a common practice, but it’s not a reliable method. Poultry may appear pink even when fully cooked, and juices can run clear before the meat has reached a safe internal temperature. Conversely, relying solely on appearance could result in overcooking your meat.

How to Avoid It:
Rather than relying on visual cues, always use a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature of your meat. Internal temperature is the only accurate way to ensure the meat is cooked to the correct doneness and is safe to eat. For example, chicken should reach an internal temperature of 165°F, while beef may vary depending on the level of doneness desired (e.g., 135°F for medium-rare).

Using a thermometer eliminates the guesswork and ensures the meat is both safe and delicious.

 

7. Using the Wrong Type of Thermometer

Not all thermometers are created equal, and using the wrong type of meat thermometer for a particular cooking method can lead to inaccurate readings and disappointing results. For instance, a slow-read dial thermometer isn’t ideal for grilling or smoking, as you may miss the critical window for perfect doneness.

Similarly, using an instant-read thermometer for oven roasting, where continuous monitoring is needed, may require you to constantly open the oven door, disrupting the cooking process.

How to Avoid It:
Use the right thermometer for the job. For grilling or smoking, a fast-acting wireless thermometer like the MeatStick is ideal because it allows you to monitor the internal temperature in real-time and remotely. You don’t need to open the oven or grill frequently to check the temperature, preserving the heat and maintaining consistent cooking.

For oven roasting, a leave-in oven-safe thermometer may be more practical, as it enables continuous monitoring without disturbing the cooking process.

 

Mastering Meat Thermometer Use

Using a meat thermometer correctly can transform your cooking experience and guarantee food security by ensuring your meat dish is cooked to the proper doneness. By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll get more accurate temperature readings, avoid undercooked or overcooked meat, and elevate your meals.

Tools like wireless thermometers make it even easier by providing real-time temperature monitoring, so you no longer have to rely on guesswork. With The MeatStick, you can monitor your food’s temperature remotely, ensuring it reaches the exact temperature without overcooking. Whether you’re grilling, roasting, or smoking, a meat thermometer ensures precision, flavor, and attention to food safety every time.

EXPLORE YOUR MEATSTICK

The Smart Wireless Meat Thermometer for Every Cook

MeatStick 4

Next Gen Quad Sensors

MeatStick Chef

The Smallest MeatStick

MeatStick

Classic Duo Sensors

What's the difference?

Compare MeatStick 4, MeatStick Chef and Classic MeatStick

*WiFi Connection requires WiFi Bridge

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.